• Home
  • About OTRU
    • Who We Are
      • Staff
      • Scientific Advisors
      • Affiliated Scientists
    • Events
    • Contact Us
  • Topics
  • Publications
  • Resources
    • Current Abstracts
      • Current Abstracts Archives
    • Webinars
    • Partner Resources

Is Blue the New Green? Repackaging Menthol Cigarettes in Response to a Flavour Ban in Ontario, Canada

October 07, 2018
by newadmin
Comments are off

Abstract

Background: As of 1 January 2017, the Canadian province of Ontario banned the distribution and sale of menthol tobacco products. There is limited knowledge about how tobacco companies will adapt their packaging in response to a menthol ban.

Methods: We conducted a content analysis of preban traditional menthol (no capsule) and menthol capsule cigarette packs and their postban replacements. Preban and postban packs were matched using tobacco company descriptions of replacement brands in business-to-business marketing materials, advertising on cigarette pack cellophane and a tobacco company website.

Results: A total of 63 menthol (n=30) and ‘non-menthol alternative’ (n=33) cigarette packs were included in the analysis. Approximately half of the preban packs were menthol capsule cigarettes and half traditional menthol cigarettes. While some postban brands continued to convey menthol-like qualities via the colour and/or brand descriptor ‘green’, ’blue’ was the most common colour and brand descriptor postban. Packs shifted from using ‘menthol’ and/or ‘fresh’ as taste descriptor preban to using ‘smooth’ postban; some postban packs had ‘non-menthol alternative’ or ‘without menthol/capsules’ written on their cellophane. The presence of innovative filter technologies continued in the postban samples.

Conclusion: Results suggest that tobacco companies attempted to maintain menthol smokers in Ontario by aggressive preban promotion of menthol capsule cigarettes, continued promotion of innovative filter technologies and by directing smokers to non-menthol alternatives whose packaging both in text and in colour connoted menthol-like qualities (eg, green) and reduced harshness or harm (eg, blue, white, silver, smooth taste).

Author(s): Tracey Borland, Sandra A D’Souza, Shawn O'Connor, Michael Chaiton, and Robert Schwartz
Date: October 2018
Type of Publication: Journal Article

Link/Download (opens in a new tab):

Borland T, D’Souza SA, O’Connor S, Chaiton MO, Schwartz R. Is blue the new green? Repackaging menthol cigarettes in response to a flavour ban in Ontario, Canada. Tobacco Control Online First: 30 October 2018. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054454.

Social Share

    Search the OTRU Website


    Expand Project

    The Expand Project is an initiative to start a dialog within queer and trans communities about smoking.

    Stop Vaping Challenge

    Download directly from your phone’s app store, or through the following links: Apple iOS devices | Android devices

    Nod From 2050

    Follow this experience to send a postcard to celebrate the younger you who decided to quit vaping.

    Our Sponsors

    Dalla Lana School of Public Health Logo
    CAMH logo

    Find Us on Social Media

    Check us out on Twitter
    Check us out on Facebook

    Sign Up for Our Monthly Emailer

    Emailer Sign Up Button Sign up for our Monthly Emailer to receive Current Abstracts, get links to new publications and be informed about webinars and events - all delivered directly to your inbox.
    © Copyright 2022 Ontario Tobacco Research Unit